Which is better - Persil or Tide, how are they similar and different from each other?

The quality of washing directly depends on the detergent. The household chemicals market offers a wide range of washing powders, gels and capsules, which are easy for the average person to get confused about.

All manufacturers guarantee the effectiveness of their product. To find out whether this is a marketing ploy and what the most famous brands of detergents really have, read the article.

We will talk about such “pillars” of household chemicals as Persil and Tide - which is better to choose and why.

Pros and cons of Persil

The German company Henkel produces Persil laundry detergents. This brand has been on the market for over 100 years. People first learned about it in 1907, and the powder appeared in Russia 20 years ago.

Main advantages Persil:

1. Variety of assortment. You can find capsules, gels and washing powder on sale.
2. High quality washing, which is proven by many years of experience and numerous tests.
3. An innovative formula that the manufacturer regularly improves.
4. Safety of the composition for the environment and human health.
5. Availability of mid-price and premium products in the line.
6. Possibility of using any detergent in cool water. The activation temperature of detergents is 30 degrees.

The disadvantages of Persil include:

1. Lack of care products in the line children's things.
2. High cost for capsules.
3. Lack of products intended exclusively for hand washing.There are only universal formulations on sale that are used for both manual and machine processing.

Advantages and Disadvantages of Tide

Branded products Tide owned by the giant Procter&Gamble corporation (USA). The world learned about the powder in 1946, and in Russia it appeared in the early seventies.

Competitive advantages Tide:

1. Consistently high demand among consumers, which has persisted for more than 50 years.
2. A wide range, including several varieties of washing powders, liquid concentrates and capsules.
3. An effective formula that the manufacturer is constantly improving. Since its creation, it has been modified more than 60 times.
4. Compliance with modern safety standards. Tide does not contain substances that are toxic to humans or harmful to the environment.
5. Affordable price.
6. High quality washing, ability to cope with stubborn stains.
7. Availability of powder for the care of baby clothes.

If you do not run an additional rinse cycle after washing, the items will emit a strong smell of household chemicals, and white stains may remain on their surface.

What do they have in common?

In some respects, Tide and Persil have similarities:

• release form (powder, capsules, gel);
• high quality washing;
• a wide range of;
• efficiency when washing in cool water (activation occurs at 30 degrees);
• similar composition of base powders, which are based on surfactants of the same concentration;
• the presence of substances that protect the washing machine from scale;
• availability of detergents for washing white and colored items.

Neither Persil nor Tide contain phosphates, which are recognized by the world scientific community as harmful to the environment and human health.

What is the difference?

Differences between detergents:

1. Various manufacturers.
2. Different price categories. Tide is cheaper than Persil: 65-75 rubles per pack of Tide Color, versus 110 rubles per pack of Persil Color.
3. The difference is in the assortment. Persil has more subtypes of gels, while Tide has more subtypes of washing powders.
4. Availability of baby laundry detergent from Tide.

Which powder to choose and in what case?

The choice of detergents is influenced by several parameters. For some, the more significant criterion is the price, and for others, the intended purpose of the gel or powder.

You need to purchase Tide household chemicals in the following cases:

1. There is a child growing in the family (they choose Tide Children's powder, which is approved by the Union of Pediatricians).
2. There is a need to save money, but without compromising the quality of the wash.
3. People like the scents presented in the Tide line, for example, “Alpine Freshness”, “Lavender and Birch Water”.
4. A person needs a product intended for hand washing only (Tide effect Lenor for hand washing).

Persil gels, capsules and powders are chosen in the following cases:

1. Items need to be washed thoroughly as they have difficult stains. For such purposes, buy Persil Premium, but it will cost more than the rest of the line.
2. The consumer prefers German quality of goods.
3. A person has increased skin sensitivity. For this purpose, the Persil Sensitive series was developed with natural soap in its composition.

Comparison of two detergents

The table shows a comparison of 2 brands according to several basic criteria:

To understand which detergent washes best, it is necessary to rely not only on generalized data, but also on examinations conducted by independent organizations.

One of these tests was carried out by Roskontrol.. The washing involved cotton fabric, which was stained with 11 types of contaminants (fruit and vegetable purees, cosmetics, sauces, drinks, shoe polish, gouache, etc.).

According to the results of the study, it was found that the highest results were obtained when washing with Persil powder. The powder worked great on stains from red wine, chocolate and herbs. Experts considered its disadvantages to be high cost, high consumption and a pungent odor.

Tide was ranked among the "good guys". It worked best on red wine, coffee and greens stains. The powder washed off cherries and chocolate worse.

Foaming was moderate for both brands. There was enough foam for effective washing, but not too much that it came out of the washing machine tray.

Reviews

On the Internet you can find different reviews left by consumers o Persil and Tide.There are people who prefer Procter & Gamble products.

They value it for its affordable price, good cleaning ability, and sufficient foaming. Families with small children often purchase Tide Children's powder.

You can find both positive and negative reviews about Persil. Many consumers indicate that the quality of washing powder has recently dropped sharply. The product no longer copes with complex stains.

Other housewives, on the contrary, are 100% satisfied with the effectiveness of household chemicals produced under this brand. They cite the high cost of capsules and liquid concentrates as its main disadvantage, but point out that they wash better than powder.

Conclusion

Both Persil and Tide can be called worthy representatives of laundry detergents. They have a wide range, cope well with their basic function and are available for purchase for most consumers.